Cato de Agua is the best yet. It is difficult to wind your way into the bay thru some very shallow and abundant reef, but well worth it. The snorkeling is great, we saw a bunch of lobsters, which is rare because they get eaten pretty quickly by cruisers. The best part though is that two islands are joined by a narrow sand strip that is almost a foot deep. The waves come crashing in from three directions and the boogie boarding is amazing. We spent three days in the surf. Zack and Robin had an amazing time. David and I even got out there. We could stay here forever but the food is running out and the laundry isn't getting any fresher. Look for videos of Zack surfing the waves soon.