We moved back over to Pigeon Point today. I can safely say after viewing all of the islands anchorages from shore and having stayed in a few and talk to folks who have stayed in all of them, Pigeon Point is the calmest of the lot. The Caribbean anchorages are all nice but they can get rolly. Even Pigeon Point can be a little rolly, but less so than any other. I would rate Tobago very highly as a destination but the one draw back is the lack of highly protected anchorages.